Short answer: A check dam slows runoff across a gully floor so sediment and plant litter can settle and vegetation can take hold. It may suit a small eroding drainage line where the bed needs to recover. It will not, by itself, stop a gully head cutting back into a paddock or repair a leaking farm dam.
After rain, a fan of fresh sand at a farm dam inlet is easy to see. The harder question is where that material came from. Walk the drainage line on safe ground and you might find a bare bed, a collapsing sidewall or a step eating its way uphill. Those are different problems, even when the sediment ends up in the same place.
Before pricing rock, decide what change you want to see. More grass on a bare gully floor is one objective. Stopping the paddock edge from retreating is another. Keeping fine clay out of a downstream storage is a third. A photograph of sediment accumulating behind a barrier can look encouraging without telling you whether the job you paid for has been done.
What does a check dam change on the gully floor?
A porous barrier lets water through gaps while slowing it locally. The gully floor, or bed, is the bottom of the eroded channel. Where runoff loses enough energy, material it was carrying can settle upstream of the barrier. That deposit can also hold leaf litter and seed. The useful result is not a permanent pool; it is a patch of ground on which plants have a better chance of surviving the next runoff event.
The Australian Government’s Reef Trust toolbox for gully and streambank work treats porous barriers as one part of rehabilitation. It pairs them with grazing management and, where needed, stock exclusion. A barrier has finite room to store material. If its upstream pocket fills and nothing takes root, a full pocket is all you have demonstrated.
This is a narrower job than protecting the banks around a storage. For bare soil along the dam margin rather than a concentrated flow path feeding it, start with our farm dam erosion-control guide. A barrier across the nearest hollow is not a substitute for finding the source of the sediment.
Is the bed eroding, or is the gully head moving?
A headcut is the step or drop at the upstream end of an incised channel. If its edge retreats, land that was paddock becomes part of the gully. Look at that edge from well back on stable ground. Compare it with an older photograph that includes the same fence post or tree. A fresh vertical face farther up the paddock tells a different story from litter settling on the floor below.
It is quite possible for the two things to happen together. An owner could photograph grass growing behind a barrier while losing ground at the head. The Reef Trust guidance does not recommend porous floor barriers as a way to stabilise an advancing headcut. In that case the assessment needs to follow the runoff above the drop and examine the head itself, not start with the width of the bed below it.
Sidewalls deserve their own photographs. A stable strip down the middle of a gully is little comfort if fresh soil is falling in from either side. Mark which bank has changed and whether the damage is at the same point as an inlet, a bend or the end of an existing structure. Report what you can see without climbing down the face to obtain a measurement.
| What you see | What it may mean | What to check next |
|---|---|---|
| Litter and coarse sand gathering on the bed | Material is settling at this point. | Is ground cover establishing, and are the head and banks holding position? |
| A fresh step farther uphill | The head may still be retreating. | Compare fixed landmarks and trace incoming runoff from safe ground. |
| A new cut around one end of the structure | Flow may be bypassing the barrier. | Record the new route and ask for a review before adding rock. |
| Muddy water leaving a partly vegetated reach | Bed recovery does not prove fine particles are being retained. | Separate the vegetation objective from the downstream water-quality objective. |
What do the Australian field results actually show?
An eight-year field experiment in north-east Australian savanna compared two treated gullies with four untreated gullies. That is a useful observation period, but not a large sample from which to promise the same result on a different property.
The researchers reported a reduction of more than 80 per cent in total sediment yield with small porous structures and cattle exclusion, and only where contributing catchments were under 10 hectares. Sediment yield is the amount leaving the area over a period, not the size of the pile you can see on the bed.
Fine sediment yield fell by 7 per cent in one treated gully and 19 per cent in the other. Fine sediment here means silt and clay; the results for those particles were not the same as the result for all material combined.
For a landholder worried about a silting inlet, that distinction changes the question to put to a contractor. Is the expensive problem coarse material building a fan at the inlet, or fine material travelling through the water? If both matter, ask how each will be assessed. Do not accept a percentage for total sediment as a promise about either water clarity or how often your dam will need cleaning out.
The Reef Trust toolbox gives a separate screening figure for revegetating gully floors in shallow soils: preferably no more than 2 hectares draining to the proposed point. The contributing catchment is the land directing runoff there, not the area inside the gully or the size of the whole property.
For low-relief country with deep, permeable soils, the toolbox gives an upper figure of 6 hectares for that revegetation use. These figures are guidance for a particular setting. The field experiment’s observation below 10 hectares does not extend the toolbox guidance or establish a construction threshold for NSW or Queensland farms.
How do you judge whether the treatment is earning its keep?
Take a baseline before disturbing the ground. Choose a viewpoint you can find again without approaching an undercut edge, and include something fixed in the frame. A close photograph of gravel is useful for showing texture. A wider one from the same visit is what lets you place that gravel in relation to the banks, the head and the path the water took.
- Name the outcome you want to judge, such as bed cover, head position or sediment reaching the inlet.
- Photograph the bed, the head and both banks from repeatable positions on stable ground.
- Sketch where runoff enters, where stock cross and where water leaves the reach.
- Revisit from the same viewpoints after runoff has passed and access is safe.
- Keep the changes together by date, including dry periods, grazing changes and any repairs.
Include the downstream side in the record. Scour is the removal of bed or bank material by flowing water. A growing hole below a barrier or a fresh channel around its end warrants review, even if there is an impressive deposit upstream. Raising the crest to catch more sediment changes where the next flow can go; get the changed route assessed rather than trying to restore the photograph you expected.
Keep the dry photographs, too. The savanna researchers observed recovery in wetter periods and setbacks in drought. If the best photograph was taken after a wet season, compare it with a later view before deciding that vegetation has become established. A brief green flush and a bed that retains cover through successive seasons are different outcomes.
What information makes a site inspection useful?
Bring a property map marked with the gully head, the proposed reach and the downstream asset you want to protect. Mark uncertain boundaries as uncertain. Include any track drains, culverts or stock crossings that feed the reach. If the damage begins at a pipe outlet, our guide to erosion at farm-track culverts explains why the outlet and the downstream channel need to be considered together.
It also helps to say what the problem is not. In 2020, at Razorback Mountain south of Sydney, Big Ditch’s Lindsey Hughson recorded the final four tonnes of bentonite being worked into a leaking wall. Despite wet, slippery conditions, the remaining repair work was completed. The Razorback repair diary describes a job intended to retain water. A porous gully treatment is deliberately meant to pass it. Do not use the material schedule for one as a shopping list for the other.
Before asking for a price, tell the assessor which outcome would justify the spend and who can look after the site afterwards. If stock cannot be kept off the recovering bed, or nobody can inspect after runoff, say so at the outset. Send the map and dated photographs with your Big Ditch inspection enquiry. Ask for the upstream cause, the treatment limits and the follow-up work to be addressed separately.
Frequently asked questions
Is water meant to pass through the structure?
Yes, if it was designed as a porous gully treatment. The intention is to slow water locally and help the bed recover, not to create a watertight stock-water reserve. Water finding a fresh path around the end is a different observation from water passing through the intended section. Photograph the route from a safe bank once flows have subsided and show it to the person responsible for the work.
Does a deposit behind the rocks prove the work succeeded?
It proves material settled there, not that the whole gully is stable. Check the outcome you originally wanted: whether bare ground is gaining persistent cover, whether the head has stopped retreating or whether less sediment is reaching the dam inlet. A deposit is a useful piece of that record. It cannot, on its own, tell you how much fine material left the site during a storm.
What if the gully starts where a farm track drains?
Include the track and its drainage in the assessment rather than treating only the channel below. A photograph taken looking upstream from safe ground can show a culvert or a wheel track that is missing from a close view of the erosion. Mark where the runoff came from and where it went. Do not redirect it into another paddock or drainage line without having that route assessed.
Would a check dam address your gully problem? Book a site inspection with Big Ditch to assess the erosion source before ordering rock.


Practical dam advice, straight to your inbox
Get an email when Big Ditch publishes a new article about dam construction, repairs or water management.
Get dam updates
Confirm your email to subscribe. Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy